cordas v peerlesslarge commercial planters
Discussion. As a lonely chauffeur in defendants employ, he became in a trice the protagonist in a breath-bating drama with a denouncement most tragic.. The cabbie, scared out of his wits, jumped out of his moving cab; the robber shortly followed suit. A reasonable man can be expected to protect himself Roberts v. State of Louisiana Jury musty apply standard of what a reasonable person would do if reasonable person was blind. > The latter entered a taxicab, which went south toward 25th street on 2nd avenue. To call him negligent would be to brand him coward; the court does not do so in spite of what those swaggering heroes, 'whose valor plucks dead lions by the beard', may bluster to the contrary. Under extremely urgent circumstances: own life was in danger; There are no instructions per se. These are excerpts from a real negligence case and a real judges opinion. As a lowly chauffeur in defendant's employ he became in a trice the protagonist in a breach-bating drama with a denouement almost tragic. To What Standard of Conduct Is a Child Held? To those commentators above who feel that the opinion is awesomely bad, or possibly the worst opinion ever, I am curious as to your basis, or bases, for coming to that conclusion. required to exercise unerring judgment, which would be expected of him, were Copyright 2023 StudeerSnel B.V., Keizersgracht 424, 1016 GC Amsterdam, KVK: 56829787, BTW: NL852321363B01, Psychology (David G. Myers; C. Nathan DeWall), Principles of Environmental Science (William P. Cunningham; Mary Ann Cunningham), Chemistry: The Central Science (Theodore E. Brown; H. Eugene H LeMay; Bruce E. Bursten; Catherine Murphy; Patrick Woodward), Educational Research: Competencies for Analysis and Applications (Gay L. R.; Mills Geoffrey E.; Airasian Peter W.), Business Law: Text and Cases (Kenneth W. Clarkson; Roger LeRoy Miller; Frank B. There are many variations of passages of Lorem Ipsum available, but the majority have suffered alteration in some form, by injected humour, or randomised words which dont look even slightly believable. If the marginal cost of increasing production by one unit is more than your current average total cost, then average total cost of producing that extra unit ___. Does the Reasonable Person Follow Customary Practice? Cordas v. Peerless Transportation Co. (NY 1941) "This case presents the ordinary man - that problem child of the law - in a most bizarre setting. Why is the cab company charged with negligence? pulled on the emergency break and jumped out of the car and the car hit a mother and her 2 kid 2. His grammar? [further facts and a discussion of negligence redacted], Returning to our chauffeur. Learn how your comment data is processed. says: 'The law in this state does not hold one in an emergency to the exercise of that mature judgment required of him under circumstances where he has an opportunity for deliberate action. Cordas v. Peerless Transp. CARLIN, Justice. 1L of a Ride: A Well-Traveled Professor's Roadmap to Success in the First Year of Law School, The 'Companion Text' to Law School: Understanding and Surviving Life with a Law Student, Practical Global Tort Litigation: United States, Germany and Argentina, The Law School Trip: The Insider's Guide to Law School, Amicus Humoriae: An Anthology of Legal Humor, Preying on the Graying: A Statutory Presumption to Prosecute Elder Financial Exploitation, Fight Club: Doctors vs. Lawyers - A Peace Plan Grounded in Self Interest, Neurotic, Paranoid Wimps - Nothing has Changed, Kiss and Tell: Protecting Intimate Relationship Privacy Through Implied Contracts of Confidentiality, Dead Sorrow: A Story About Loss and A New Theory of Wrongful Death Damages, A Thousand Words are Worth a Picture: A Privacy Tort Response to Consumer Data Profiling, The Public Health Case for the Safe Storage of Firearms: Adolescent Suicides Add One More 'Smoking Gun', Armed and Dangerous: Tort Liability for the Negligent Storage of Firearms, Good Cop, Bad Cop: Using Cognitive Dissonance Theory to Reduce Police Lying, Poetry in Commotion: Katko v. Briney and the Bards of First-Year Torts, The Tortious Marketing of Handguns: Strict Liability is Dead, Long Live Negligence, Bringing Privacy Law Out of the Closet: A Tort Theory of Liability for Intrusions in Public Places, Its a Wonderful Life: The Case for Hedonic Damages in Wrongful Death Cases, Your Money or Your Life: Interpreting the Federal Act Against Patient Dumping, Logical Fallacies and the Supreme Court: A Critical Analysis of Justice Rehnquist's Decisions In Criminal Procedure Cases. The plaintiff and her infant children were injured by the cab. Instead, . It appears that a man, whose identity it would be indelicate to divulge was feloniously relieved of his portable goods by two nondescript highwaymen in an alley near 26th Street and Third Avenue, Manhattan; they induced him to relinquish his possessions by a strong argument ad hominem couched in the convincing cant of the criminal and pressed at the point of a most persuasive pistol. The care or caution required is according to the capacity of the child, and this is to be determined, ordinarily, by the age of the age of the child. He abandoned the car in the highway where a cab containing a mother and child ran onto the embankment and were injured. The circumstances provide the foil by which the act is brought into relief to determine whether it is or is not negligent. . Cordas sued Peerless for negligence. Returning to our chauffeur. Anyway, Cordas's attorneys sound like the worst kind of ambulance-chasers. The learned attorney for the plaintiffs concedes that the chauffeur acted in an emergency but claims a right to recovery upon the following proposition taken verbatim from his brief: 'It is respectfully submitted that the value of the interests of the public at large to be immune from being injured by a dangerous instrumentality such as a car unattended while in motion is very superior to the right of a driver of a motor vehicle to abandon same while it is in motion even when acting under the belief that his life is in danger and by abandoning same he will save his life'. NY Times Paywall - Case Analysis with questions and their answers. Negligence is 'not absolute or intrinsic,' but 'is always relevant to some circumstances of time, place or person.' Court finds he acted reasonably given the emergency situation. [. Stick with your blog reading! GOVT 280- Cordas v. Peerless Transportaion 's cab driver was stopped when someone jumped in his car and held a gun to him and said he would kill him. actions were in response to an emergency situation. We use AI to automatically extract content from documents in our library to display, so you can study better. 17: Iss. Laden with their loot, but not thereby impeded, they took an abrupt departure and he, shuffling off the coil of that discretion which enmeshed him in the alley, quickly gave chase through 26th Street towards 2d Avenue, whither they were resorting with expedition swift as thought for most obvious reasons. holds that actionable negligence must be predicated upon 'a breach of duty to the plaintiff. Issue 5. Richmond, Michael L. (1993) "The Annotated Cordas," Nova Law Review: Vol. The chauffeur in reluctant acquiescence proceeded about fifteen feet, when his hair, like unto the quills of the fretful porcupine, was made to stand on end by the hue and cry of the man despoiled accompanied by a clamorous concourse of the law-abiding which paced him as he ran; the concatenation of 'stop thief', to which the patter of persistent feet did maddingly beat time, rang in his ears as the pursuing posse all the while gained on the receding cab with its quarry therein contained. Amazing how the brain works to block out trauma. In fright, the chauffeur slammed on the brakes and jumped out of the vehicle, which kept moving and hit the plaintiff pedestrian and her children (fortunately, injuries were slight). I think I just read the worst written opinion ever. Note: The following opinion was edited by LexisNexis Courtroom Cast staff. Holding Thanks to all the folks whosent in this classic. of pressing danger was done or neglected involuntarily. Full Document. 2, Article 30. Cordas v. Peerless Transportation Co. City Court of New York, New York County, 1941 27 N.Y.S.2d 198 Listen to the opinion: Tweet Brief Fact Summary Plaintiff's children and wife were struck by a taxi, whose driver abandoned it. The Understanding Law Video Lecture Series: Monthly Subscription ($19 / Month) His use of metaphor? | The car, now driverless, ran up onto a sidewalk and injured the Plaintiff, Cordas (Plaintiff), a pedestrian. Cost of staying in car to gather more data was very high relative to the risk of being shot by the mugger A taxi driver working for the Defendant, Peerless Transportation Co. (Defendant), jumped from his taxi while it was running to escape an armed highwayman who was being pursued by his victim. Justice Carlin wrote denouement, not denouncement. The two terms have completely different meanings. Accessibility Statement Yeah. In Cordas v. Peerless Transportation Co. (1941), a taxi driver employed by the defendant company jumped from his moving taxi to escape an armed robber being chased by Cordas (the victim and. In slight paraphrase of the world's first bard it may be truly observed that the expedition of the chauffeur's violent love of his own security outran the pauser, reason, when he was suddenly confronted with unusual emergency which 'took his reason prisoner'. [. : an American History, 1.1 Functions and Continuity full solutions. Thats exactly what I had to do as I read it. Translation: Its not negligent to react in fright when a carjacker has a gun pointed at your head. him, if he were not faced with a situation needing immediate response. The cab driver jumped out of the car and ran towards 26th street, while the 8. Man chases the muggers, and the muggers split up. Every Bundle includes the complete text from each of the titles below: PLUS: Hundreds of law school topic-related videos from Indeed, our Courts have long recognized that one who engages in a business, occupation, or profession must exercise the requisite degree of learning, skill, ability of that calling with reasonable and ordinary care. LOL Your analysis was great! Cordas v. Peerless Transportation Co. (Reasonable and prudent person) D had a chauffeur who was approached by 2 men in an alley they flashed a gun and then went on a highspeed chase. Judgment for defendant against plaintiffs dismissing their complaint upon the merits. Carlin apparently was a learned Shakespeare fan. Note that not all of the publications that are listed have parallel citations. In excusing the chauffeur from liability for jumping out of the moving vehicle, Carlin said: If the philosophic Horatio and the martial companions of his watch were distilled almost to jelly with the act of fear when they beheld in the dead vast and middle of night the disembodied spirit of Hamlets father stalk majestically by with a countenance more in sorrow than in anger, was not the chauffeur, though unacquainted with the example of these eminent men-at-arms more amply justified in his fearsome reactions when he was more palpably confronted by a thing of flesh and blood bearing in its hand an engine of destruction which depended for its lethal purpose upon the quiver of a hair. and he, shuffling off the coil of that discretion which enmeshed him in the alley, quickly gave chase, 3. Get answers and explanations from our Expert Tutors, in as fast as 20 minutes, Unformatted text preview: Facts : A taxi driver working for Peerless Transportation Company (Peerless) (defendant) jumped out of his taxi cab while the car was still moving in order to escape an armed man chasing another individual. The chauffeur in reluctant acquiescence proceeded about fifteen feet when his hair, like unto the quills of the fretful porcupine, was made to stand on end by the hue and cry of the man despoiled, 5. The language of the opinion keeps getting worse. Kolanka v. Erie Railroad Co., . Motions, upon which decision was reserved, to dismiss the complaint are granted with exceptions to plaintiffs. The defendant was a chauffeur and the victim of an armed car-jacking by a fleeing robber who threatened to blow the chauffeur's brains out. There is a general agreement that if the emergency is created by negligence of the actor the emergency doctrine does not apply. The chauffeur, apprehensive of certain dissolution from either Scylla, the pursuers, or Charybdis, the pursued, quickly threw his car out of first speed in which, he was proceeding, pulled on the emergency, jammed on his brakes, and, although he thinks the motor was still running, swung open the door to his left and jumped out of his car.. Section Two 5 points DIRECTIONS: Provide any parallel publications that exist for each of the sources listed below. His syntax? Two highwaymen robbed a man (whose identity is undisclosed) at gunpoint in an The alleged cause of action was that the cabbie was negligent in jumping out of a moving vehicle that he was putatively in control of; the court found that he was unable to exercise the standard of reasonable care due to the large gun pointed at his head and thus was not negligent. Facts TRIMARCO v. KLEIN 4. regarded negligent under ordinary circumstances, such as when they are Returning to our chauffeur. If the philosophic Horatio and the martial companions of his watch were distilled almost to jelly with the act of fear when they beheld in the dead vast and middle of the night the disembodied spirit of Hamlets father stalk majestically by with a countenance more in sorrow than in anger was not the chauffeur, though unacquainted with the example of these eminent men-at-arms, more amply justified in his fearsome reactions when he was more palpably confronted by a thing of flesh and blood bearing in its hand an engine of destruction which depended for its lethal purpose upon the quiver of a hair? If under normal circumstances an act is done which might be considered negligent, it does not follow as a corollary that a similar act is negligent if performed by a person acting under an emergency, not of his own making, in which he suddenly is faced with a patent danger with a moment left to adapt a mean of extrication. Co., 27 N.Y.S.2d 198, 199, 201 (City Court of N.Y. 1941). If you are interested, please contact us at [email protected] Cross), Biological Science (Freeman Scott; Quillin Kim; Allison Lizabeth), Civilization and its Discontents (Sigmund Freud), Forecasting, Time Series, and Regression (Richard T. O'Connell; Anne B. Koehler), Brunner and Suddarth's Textbook of Medical-Surgical Nursing (Janice L. Hinkle; Kerry H. Cheever), The Methodology of the Social Sciences (Max Weber), Campbell Biology (Jane B. Reece; Lisa A. Urry; Michael L. Cain; Steven A. Wasserman; Peter V. Minorsky), Give Me Liberty! Yeah, well, the verbiage is all very nice, but what the hell is this case about? Two houses away, at 1236 Any Street, is, Your client, Ms. Kimberly Hall, stands convicted under your state law for charges involving theft, trafficking in stolen property, fraud, and alteration of vehicle identification numbers.Hall runs a. After both parties presented evidence at trial, Peerless moved to dismiss the complaint. Then state whether the argument is valid or invalid. danger and can't get away. Other employees prepare the orders. Who is Cordas -- the gunman, the driver, the mugging victim, or the poor SOB who got rear-ended when the driver bailed out of his cab? The care taken by a prudent man had always been the rule laid down. driverless car and its passenger mounted the sidewalk on 24th street. And when such language does occur, it occurs almost invariably at the expense of legal analysis. 1L year is painfully dry and devoid of, even hostile to, eloquence and style. Copyright. CASE BRIEF WORKSHEET Title of Case: Cordas v.Peerless Transportation Co., City Ct. of NY 1941 Facts (relevant; if any changed, the holding would be affected; used by the court to make its decision; what happened before the lawsuit was filed): D was a cab driver. My Account Vendas pela Editora da UFPB (Telefone: (83) 3216-7147; E-mail: atendimento.editora.ufpb@gmail.com ) Apresentao do prof. Dr. lvaro Bragana Jnior (UFRJ): "Com o ttulo Na trilha dos vikings: estudos de religiosidade nrdica, o professor e pesquisador Johnni Langer brinda o leitor brasileiro com mais uma obra que, sem dvida, se tornar mais uma referncia no campo de estudos da . He confesses that the only act that smacked of intelligence was that by which he jammed the brakes in order to throw off balance the hold-up man who was half-standing and half-sitting with his pistol menacingly poised. The case stands for the unremarkable principle that under the basic negligence standard of reasonable care under the circumstances, people arent expected to exercise as much care in emergency situations as in non-emergencies where they have time to weigh and deliberate. Peerless PDA View Full Version : Cordas v. Peerless D. Scarlatti 08-21-2005, 01:24 PM CARLIN, Justice. Whether abandoning a running car is considered to be reasonable, The trial court dismissed the complaint in favor of the defendant. Luckily this opinion is the exception (rather than the rule) for my textbooks. . Plaintiff: Cordas I.e., where are the flaws? It also stands as a literary masterpiece of judicial opinion writing. The hold-up man sensing his insecurity suggested to the chauffeur that in the event there was the slightest lapse in obedience to his curt command that he, the chauffeur, would suffer the loss of his brains, a prospect as horrible to an humble chauffeur as it undoubtedly would be to one of the intelligentsia. Full Document, Business Law- Case Brief for Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad Company.pdf, Business Law- Bell v. Irace Case Brief.pdf, Law 402 Class 26 Case Brief of Tarasoff v. University of California.docx, The address on your evidence documentation must be the same address provided to, Nothing happens A string is printed to the standard out An instance of the class, A simple approach to represent nominal variables in a dataset is to assign a, Vitamin A as retinol Milk yoghurt and cheese Vitamin A as betacarotene Milk and, When a teacher and students create a text together they engage in a proofreading, No part of this document may be reproduced in any form or by any means without, Pinching the nerve under the biceps brachii muscle to bring it closer to the, The Federal and State court systems have similar.docx, How the Great Migration shaped African American churches- Angela Hodges.docx, BSBWOR301_Student Assessment TH v2.0.docx, D2B38D5F-68B8-48B9-8DF2-CE79AD58806C.jpeg, Select the statement that is true of consumer law prior to the 20th century. Year is painfully dry and devoid of, even hostile to, eloquence style... Child ran onto the embankment and were injured by the cab driver jumped out of the publications that for... Was in danger ; There are no instructions per se which decision was reserved, to dismiss complaint! The merits to the plaintiff, Cordas ( plaintiff ), a.. Ran up onto a sidewalk and injured the plaintiff, Cordas 's attorneys sound like the worst written ever! Gave chase, 3 richmond, Michael L. ( 1993 ) & quot ; the robber shortly followed suit Standard! Opinion writing, & quot ; the Annotated Cordas, & quot ; Law. Provide the foil by which the act is brought into relief to determine whether it is or not... Circumstances of time, place or person. while the 8 toward 25th street 2nd! Full Version: Cordas I.e., where are the flaws situation needing immediate response to,. Not faced with a situation needing immediate response to what Standard of Conduct is a Child Held regarded negligent ordinary! It also stands as a literary masterpiece of judicial opinion writing case about to all folks... By the cab driver jumped out of the publications that are listed have parallel citations chases the muggers, the... Of Conduct is a Child Held v. KLEIN 4. regarded negligent under ordinary circumstances, such when... To dismiss the complaint are granted with exceptions to plaintiffs, ran up cordas v peerless a sidewalk and the. As when they are Returning to our chauffeur, it occurs almost invariably at the expense of legal.! Employ, he became in a trice the protagonist in a trice protagonist. Painfully dry and devoid of, even hostile to, eloquence and style ), a pedestrian negligence of sources! ' a breach of duty to the plaintiff and her infant children were injured: Vol I.e.. Circumstances: own life was in danger ; There are no instructions per se parallel citations complaint! Whether the argument is valid or invalid following opinion was edited by Courtroom. Which the act is brought into relief to determine whether it is is. Most tragic is this case about 1l year is painfully dry and devoid,! The folks whosent in this classic gave chase, 3 brought into relief to determine whether it or. The latter entered a taxicab, which went south toward 25th street on 2nd avenue he the... Judgment for defendant against plaintiffs dismissing their complaint upon the merits - case Analysis with questions and their answers the! Read the worst kind of ambulance-chasers exception ( rather than the rule ) my. Continuity full solutions pointed at your head for defendant against plaintiffs dismissing their complaint the... As when they are Returning to our chauffeur the complaint street on 2nd.... The emergency break and jumped out of his wits, jumped out of his wits jumped. The protagonist in a trice the protagonist in a breath-bating drama with a most. This case about what the hell is this case about alley, quickly gave chase, 3 full... If he were not faced with a denouncement most tragic a lonely chauffeur in defendants employ, he in. American History, 1.1 Functions and Continuity full solutions, shuffling off the coil that! Must be predicated upon ' a breach of duty to the plaintiff, Cordas plaintiff. Its not negligent is all very nice, but what the hell this... Are excerpts from a real judges opinion under ordinary circumstances, such as when they are Returning to chauffeur. Created by negligence of the defendant 198, 199, 201 ( City court of N.Y. 1941.! Worst written opinion ever employ, he became in a breath-bating drama with a denouncement most tragic ran... Nova Law Review: Vol to determine whether it is or is not negligent denouncement tragic... And when such language does occur, it occurs almost invariably at expense! Is painfully dry and devoid of, even hostile to, eloquence and style exactly I! Of N.Y. 1941 ) a Child Held, so you can study better, the trial court dismissed the are. His moving cab ; the robber shortly followed suit gave chase, 3 shortly followed suit whether... The merits ) & quot ; Nova Law Review: Vol it almost! A real negligence case and a discussion of negligence redacted ], Returning to our chauffeur favor.: Its not negligent to react in fright when a carjacker has a gun pointed your! Which the act is brought into relief to determine whether it is or is not negligent to in... Dry and devoid of, even hostile to, eloquence and style her 2 2... Exceptions to plaintiffs do as I read it for each of the defendant quickly gave chase cordas v peerless.! Or invalid Its passenger mounted the sidewalk on 24th street emergency is created by negligence of the defendant of to... Always relevant to some circumstances of time, place or person. read. The circumstances provide the foil by which the act is brought into relief to determine whether it is is. Negligence must be predicated upon ' a breach of duty to the plaintiff by a prudent man always! Is brought into relief to determine whether it is or is not negligent employ, he became a! Muggers, and the muggers, and the muggers split up we AI. Ordinary circumstances, such as when they are Returning to our chauffeur with exceptions to.... Onto the embankment and were injured Thanks to all the folks whosent in this classic Lecture. Sidewalk and injured the plaintiff and her infant children were injured year painfully... Which went south toward 25th street on 2nd avenue note that not of! Doctrine does not apply shortly followed suit edited by LexisNexis Courtroom Cast staff court... The car, now driverless, ran up onto a sidewalk and the. Our chauffeur kid 2 $ 19 / Month ) his use of metaphor a taxicab, which south! What Standard of Conduct is a Child Held note that not all of the that... Driverless, ran up onto a sidewalk and injured the plaintiff and her 2 kid.. Eloquence and style American History, 1.1 Functions and Continuity full solutions infant! As when they are Returning to our chauffeur redacted ], Returning to our chauffeur, to... Circumstances of time, place or person. out trauma rule ) for my textbooks of... Negligence redacted ], Returning to our chauffeur display, so you can study better rule laid.! Relief to determine whether it is or is not negligent yeah,,. Negligent to react in fright when a carjacker has a gun pointed at your head judges opinion Child. The care taken by a prudent man had always been the rule for.: the following opinion was edited by LexisNexis Courtroom Cast staff literary of! We use AI to automatically extract content from documents in our library to cordas v peerless. Peerless moved to dismiss the complaint in favor of the car, now driverless, ran up onto sidewalk. V. Peerless D. Scarlatti 08-21-2005, 01:24 PM CARLIN, Justice Peerless moved to dismiss the in! The exception ( rather than the rule laid down to plaintiffs agreement that if the is! Instructions per se / Month ) his use of metaphor Video Lecture Series: Monthly Subscription ( $ /!, 201 ( City court of N.Y. 1941 ) decision was reserved, to dismiss the complaint 'not. The muggers split up intrinsic, ' but 'is always relevant to some circumstances of,. ) for my textbooks Version: Cordas v. Peerless D. Scarlatti 08-21-2005, 01:24 PM,. Or invalid and were injured listed have parallel citations facts and a real judges opinion circumstances of,... The act is brought into relief to determine whether it is or is not negligent carjacker has a pointed... 5 points DIRECTIONS: provide any parallel publications that are listed have parallel citations eloquence. Muggers cordas v peerless up is the exception ( rather than the rule laid down real case. Reasonable, the verbiage is all very nice, but what the hell is this case about,! Is or is not negligent Conduct is a Child Held 19 / Month ) use! This classic on 24th street View full Version: Cordas v. Peerless D. Scarlatti 08-21-2005, PM. Brought into relief to determine whether it is or is not negligent this case about breach! This opinion is the exception ( rather than the rule laid down to circumstances! Been the rule ) for my textbooks to block out trauma chauffeur defendants... Well, the verbiage is all very nice, but what the hell is this case about and answers! A mother and her infant children were injured by cordas v peerless cab driver jumped out of car... In this classic literary masterpiece of judicial opinion writing the defendant is the exception ( rather than rule... Not apply opinion ever relevant to some circumstances of time, place or.... Complaint are granted with exceptions to plaintiffs negligence is 'not absolute cordas v peerless intrinsic, ' 'is. Worst kind of ambulance-chasers circumstances: own life was in danger ; are. Is valid or invalid car is considered to be reasonable, the trial dismissed! Breach of duty to the plaintiff and her infant children were injured by the cab Standard! Up onto a sidewalk and injured the plaintiff, Cordas ( plaintiff ), a..